Follow the fee.
An investor pays one total. Part stays with the wealth provider, part goes to the fund manager, and sometimes to another manager behind that fund.
The same index exposure bought through different routes, by market type.
US, UK/Europe, Canada, Australia. Cheap index funds are widely available, advice is increasingly a separate fee, and commissions are restricted or banned.
Self-directed, index ETF
0.03% · $3 a year on $10,000Buys a large S&P 500 ETF on a commission-free brokerage (e.g. Questrade, Wealthsimple, US discount brokers).
- ETF expense ratio0.03%
- Commission ($0 on many platforms; FX and spread can apply)0.00%
No one is paid for advice. Platforms earn on FX conversion, cash balances and order flow rather than commissions.
Robo-advisor
0.35% · $35 a year on $10,000*Automated portfolio of index ETFs.
- Robo platform fee0.25%
- Underlying ETF fees0.10%
The platform keeps most of the fee for rebalancing and account service; the ETF managers keep a few bps.
Advisor, commission share class
2.00% · $200 a year on $10,000*A-series (Canada), load / 12b-1 classes (US), bundled classes (EU outside UK/NL).
- Manager fee and fund costs1.00%
- Trailing commission inside the fund fee1.00%
The investor sees one fund fee; about half typically flows back to the dealer and advisor as a trailer.
Advisor, fee-based share class
1.80% · $180 a year on $10,000*F-series (Canada), advisory or clean share classes (US, UK after the commission ban).
- Lower fund fee (no trailer)0.80%
- Separate advisor fee on the account1.00%
The fund fee drops because the trailer is removed, but the advisor bills separately. The total can exceed buying the same fund self-directed, and sometimes the commission class.
Employer plan (group RRSP / 401(k))
0.50% · $50 a year on $10,000*An insurer or bank's branded plan fund that wraps another manager's fund, e.g. a BlackRock index fund.
- Recordkeeping and plan administration (kept by provider)0.40%
- Underlying manager (sub-adviser)0.10%
The fund name belongs to the plan provider; the money is invested by another manager. Larger plans negotiate lower totals. Insurer segregated funds add a guarantee charge.
Private fund via wealth partner
4.10% · $410 a year on $10,000*Evergreen private-equity or private-credit fund sold by a bank-owned dealer or private bank.
- Management and fund expenses1.75%
- Servicing / placement fee0.85%
- Profit share in a strong year1.50%
Minimums, suitability rules and dealer agreements keep these off self-directed platforms. The profit share only appears when returns clear the hurdle.
* Typical figures for illustration; actual fees vary by firm, fund and account size. Rules that reshaped these splits: UK commission ban, US Regulation Best Interest, Canada's 2022 bans on deferred sales charges and discount-broker trailers, India's ban on upfront commissions.
Fee terms and every vehicle's fee sheet are on the fees map; who each firm is in the participants map; which rules apply to each vehicle on the rules map.